Legal news

Collective performance agreements and job eliminations

Par 13 November 2026No Comments

By Jocelyn Hagneau

In 2020, Derichebourg Aeronautics Services France considered an employment safeguard plan (PSE) involving the elimination of 700 of its 1,700 jobs. The company ultimately chose to sign a collective performance agreement (APC) to preserve jobs. This option envisaged a restructuring followed by a potentially smaller PSE.

The agreement was challenged after 160 dismissals

After the APC was signed in June 2020, 160 employees who rejected it were dismissed. UNSA-SNMSAC sought to have the agreement annulled, alleging misuse of the APC’s purpose and bad faith in the negotiations. The Toulouse Court of Appeal annulled it, finding, in view of the net elimination of 78 jobs, that collective redundancy rules had been circumvented, notably requiring the implementation of a PSE.

The Cour de cassation’s ruling

Job eliminations and validity of the APC. The agreement’s validity does not depend on whether jobs are eliminated after employees are dismissed for refusing contract changes under the APC.

Assessing potential fraud. The mere fact that 160 employees out of 1,700 rejected the APC is not sufficient to establish fraud.

Referral to the Bordeaux Court of Appeal. The annulment claim will be reheard, including whether fraud existed in light of the Cour de cassation’s judgment. The allegation of bad faith in the negotiations, which the Toulouse Court of Appeal had not ruled on, may also be considered.

IN PRACTICE

The Workwise perspective

APCs and restructuring plans

Net job eliminations do not, by themselves, invalidate an APC. It nevertheless remains essential to document the APC’s purpose, ensure that negotiations are conducted in good faith and assess its interaction with any collective redundancy process.

Jocelyn Hagneau, Workwise Avocats

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jocelyn Hagneau

Partner at Workwise Avocats · Employment and labour law

View profile →